Shingles or Metal Roofing Installation: Which Is Preferable?

Many argue about the merits of metal shingles over other roofing alternatives while building a home. Both kinds have benefits and cons. Asphalt shingles can be the best option if you’re searching for a more durable, cost-effective roof that can withstand the elements. 

Although strong, energy-saving metal roofs are a growing trend, the choice of which is best for you ultimately rests with you. When it comes time to your roof, knowing the differences between metal and shingles will help you choose what would work best for your house.

Shingles For The Roof

Shingle Roofs Are Less Expensive

They are frequently the least expensive roofing option both initially and after repairs. They don’t get damaged as easily as metal roofs do. Roof repairs are less pricey than they would be for metal roofs if they are damaged. 

Asphalt shingle roofing provides excellent protection and holds up well against flooding, so you won’t need to make as many repairs. The most economical roofing option, asphalt roofs, are excellent at keeping your home safe and warm.

Numerous Hues and Designs Available For Shingles

While asphalt gray and drab brown are the most common hues, there are additional, more vivid possibilities that let you have green, blue, red, or even white shingles. You can choose the right shingle color to complement or update your home’s appearance based on your property’s colour and style.

Shingles Are The Typical Outside Finish For Most Houses

Asphalt roofs are common, so if you choose one for your home, it will probably match the style and aesthetic of the neighborhood. 

Metal Roof

Metal roofs, in terms of longevity, lasting 40 to 70 years on average. However, if repairs are required, they cost more to fix.

The ability of the metal to withstand the elements is another distinction between metal roofs and asphalt roofs. Most metal roofs are certified to withstand winds up to 140 mph. 

They’re a sustainable roofing alternative to petroleum-based asphalt shingles and are constructed to resist corrosion and rust. Most metal roofs are composed of recycled materials and are completely recyclable. Without suffering from any loss in strength, longevity, or quality, steel roofing can be recycled again to produce more roofing.

There are numerous metals and materials to choose from, providing a large variety of possible designs to fit any home. 

Your options are tin, zinc, aluminum, copper, and galvanized steel. You can acquire many of these materials in various colors to get the exact appearance you want.

The cost of the materials used to create and manufacture a metal roof. Installing, repairing, and replacing metal roofs requires the assistance of skilled roofing contractors due to their difficulty. Metal roofs may make a lot of unwelcome noise and are fairly expensive to repair when damaged. While some individuals enjoy hearing the sound of rain on a metal roof or the accompanying white noise, others find it to be dreadfully unpleasant. Even with numerous insulation layers or sheathing to muffle the sound, it can be difficult to block out the rain during a powerful storm. 

Does a Metal Roof Increase a House’s Value?

It’s good to think about the total effect it will have on the value of your property when selecting which is better for a metal roof vs. shingles. A dazzling, brand-new metal roof installation in Saskatoon can increase a home’s value and curb appeal. As a general rule, installing a metal roof will return, on average, roughly 61% of your investment in the value of your home, while replacing your shingles will return, on average, 66%. 


The US’s two most common roofing materials are metal and asphalt shingles. Which one is better was one of homeowners’ most frequently asked questions. The solution is based on your priorities and preferences. Either way, you can seek one of the best roofing companies in Saskatoon for shingle or metal roofing installation. 

We at Wilderness Roofing provide and install seamless 5-inch eavestroughs, vinyl, Hardie siding, blown insulation, interior and exterior painting, cedar shake conversions, and flat roofing for both commercial and residential buildings. Contact us if you need metal or shingle roofing

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top